UproxxWelcome to the Crumbl Cookie report! This week will serve as the send-off for Crumbl’s current “Dessert of the Month,” the Cookies & Cream Brownie and we have to admit, we’re pretty thrilled about that. The first week of the month, we dug the Cookies & Cream Brownie, but now three weeks later, we hope to not see it in over a year. But, we have to hand it to Crumbl for attempting to find ways to keep us excited and experiment with their menu.
But let us offer some advice for our favorite cookie brand — if you want to keep customers excited, make cool cookies, the newer and more experimental, the more exciting! But enough ranting, we have some cookies to review and rank!This week doesn’t seem to have a seasonal theme or any type of theme really. It feels like a random assortment of cookies, but that’s okay because the roster is full of strong returning fan favorites. Here is what to eat and what to skip at Crumbl this week.
7. Ultimate Peanut ButterDane RiveraThoughts & Tasting Notes:Ultimate Peanut Butter? More like ultimate skip! Seriously, skip this one, unless you have an unhealthy obsession with peanut butter. My issue with this cookie is that it features three different sources of peanut butter, the cookie’s base, the inside, and the drizzle are all the same boring flat peanut butter flavor.
No jelly to add dimension, no chocolate for a rich counterbalance, it’s just peanut butter, that’s all. The Bottom Line:You have to really love peanut butter .